Former ACCC chair urges government to rethink proposed AI copyright reforms

He calls for licensing negotiations or court intervention and warns of a constitutional challenge

Former ACCC chair urges government to rethink proposed AI copyright reforms

Former Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) chairman Rod Sims has warned that the Albanese government's proposed copyright changes could turn Australia into a “tax haven” for artificial intelligence (AI) companies seeking to use protected content to train their models.

Sims, who spearheaded the News Media Bargaining Code that forced Google and Meta to pay $1 billion to Australian media companies, rejected claims that Australia's copyright laws differ significantly from those overseas, The Australian Financial Review reported.

In a speech to the Victorian Country Press Association, Sims said international news organisations and copyright owners feared AI companies were targeting Australia with promises of investment in exchange for weaker copyright protections.

“When it comes to AI taking media or creatives(’) work under copyright(,) the impact of the law appears to be the same in Australia and the US and overseas generally,” Sims said. “AI companies are seeking to get in Australia what they cannot get in the USA or elsewhere.”

The warning comes as the government considers copyright reforms amid expectations that AI could attract $150 billion in data centre investment over the next decade.

AI companies, including OpenAI and Anthropic, have sought copyright concessions to train their models, arguing that negotiating individual agreements with content creators would be impractical.

The government has proposed two options: requiring AI companies to contribute to a central fund for creators or requiring them to secure a minimum number of agreements before accessing unprotected online material.

Sims criticised both approaches and urged the government to require AI companies to negotiate commercial agreements or allow courts to resolve disputes.

“AI companies seem unwilling to engage with far fewer suppliers than supermarkets Coles or Woolworths do on a regular basis, let alone successful digital distributors like Spotify or Netflix,” he said.

He also raised the possibility that overseas rights holders could mount a constitutional challenge, arguing that the proposals involved acquiring property other than “on just terms”.

Sims said the government should leave access to copyrighted material to voluntary commercial negotiations or court proceedings, as occurs in the United States and other jurisdictions.