Federal Court grants pseudonym orders in eSafety case against Telegram

Judge sets 10-year publication ban over some identities and confidential information

Federal Court grants pseudonym orders in eSafety case against Telegram

In proceedings commenced by the eSafety Commissioner against Telegram FZ-LLC and Telegram Messenger Inc, the Australian Federal Court issued pseudonymity and non-publication orders to keep certain individuals safe and to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice. 

eSafety Commissioner v Telegram FZ-LLC (suppression orders) [2026] FCA 1700 concerned the Online Safety (Relevant Electronic Services – Class 1A and Class 1B Material) Industry Standard 2024 (Cth) (RES Standard), promulgated under s 145(1) of the Online Safety Act 2021 (Cth). 

Seeking declarations and pecuniary penalties, the applicant commissioner claimed breaches of the RES Standard that allegedly constituted contraventions of s 146(1) of the Online Safety Act. 

According to the commissioner, the contravening conduct facilitated access to or the distribution of class 1A material, defined in s 6(1) of the RES Standard as including “pro-terror material” or “extreme crime and violence material.”

In her statement of claim, the commissioner asserted that end-users in Australia: 

  • identified 12 examples of class 1A material on the Telegram service, three of which were “known pro-terror material,” defined in s 6(1) of the RES Standard as “material that has been verified as pro–terror material” 
  • reported each instance to the Telegram service provider, which failed to remove 10 of the 12 instances within seven days 

The commissioner argued that the relevant Telegram entity failed to: 

  • maintain systems and processes for responding to breaches of terms of use relating to class 1A material under ss 14(2) and 15(2) of the RES Standard 
  • set up the appropriate systems, processes, and technologies to detect, remove, disrupt, and deter known pro-terror material under ss 20(2) and 21(2) of the RES Standard 
  • give any notification in response to the complaints under s 29(4) of the RES Standard 

eSafety Commissioner’s application

In the present proceeding, the applicant commissioner asked for pseudonym orders based on witness safety considerations and the need to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice in connection with the commissioner’s: 

  • determination of whether the services abided by the Online Safety Act 
  • prosecution of civil penalty proceedings in the event of non-compliance 

The commissioner relied on the affidavits of: 

  • Ms Snell, the Office of the Commissioner’s general manager of regulatory operations 
  • the chief executive officer of the company employing two proposed trial witnesses 

The commissioner also requested non-publication orders over portions of Ms Snell’s affidavit and over the CEO’s entire affidavit. 

Federal Court’s pseudonym and non-publication orders

The Federal Court made the requested orders with some adjustments. 

According to the court, the orders would help protect the safety of individuals under s 37AG(1)(c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice under s 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act. 

Upon considering the affidavit evidence, the court issued orders to refer to the employer company as “company Y,” to refer to its CEO as “Mr X,” and to refer to the two proposed witnesses as “Person A” and “Person B.” 

The court then imposed a 10-year prohibition over: 

  • the publication of any information potentially divulging the identities of Person A, Person B, Mr X, or company Y, as well as company Y’s address 
  • the publication, disclosure, or access by most people of the following confidential information without a court order: paragraphs 13 to 15 of Ms Snell’s affidavit; Mr X’s affidavit to the extent that it identified company Y, Mr X, Person A, or Person B; and the commissioner’s written submissions on 5 November 2026, to the extent that they identified company Y, Mr X, Person A, or Person B 

Lastly, the court reserved the issue of costs. 

Previous news stories on eSafety Commissioner

In late July, the eSafety Commissioner announced the commencement of civil penalty proceedings before the Federal Court against Telegram’s provider based on its alleged failure to detect and remove pro-terror material from the platform, including videos of terrorist executions and mass shootings. 

On 21 May 2026, the Federal Court of Australia ordered X Corp, which operated the social media service formerly known as Twitter, to pay $650k to the Commonwealth of Australia as a pecuniary penalty and $100k as a contribution to the eSafety Commissioner’s costs. 

Enjoy this story? Read the latest TMT (telecoms, media, technology) law news on the main page!