High Court upholds visa denial by immigration and citizenship minister

Judges say delegate weighed relevant matters in assessing child’s best interests

High Court upholds visa denial by immigration and citizenship minister
High Court of Australia

The Australian High Court has affirmed the 26 May 2026 decision of a delegate of the defendant, the minister for immigration and citizenship, that had rejected the plaintiff’s application for the issuance of a Return (Residence) (Class BB) visa. 

In an application for a constitutional or other writ filed on 2 July 2026, the plaintiff in Hatewar v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] HCA 45 invoked the High Court’s original jurisdiction under s 75(v) of the Constitution. 

In his application, the plaintiff sought writs of certiorari and mandamus directing the defendant minister to quash the delegate’s decision and to require the determination of the visa application according to law. 

High Court’s order

Upon determining that the plaintiff had failed on all the grounds he had raised, Gageler CJ and Jagot J of the High Court denied his application with costs. 

Operation of Direction 110

The High Court ruled that the delegate: 

  • did not misunderstand or misapply para 5.2(2) of Direction 110 
  • considered each of the matters in paras 8.1–8.5 of the direction, as required 
  • assigned the greatest weight to the considerations reflecting the terms of para 5.2(2), properly construed 

Upon considering the plaintiff’s submissions, the court found that they did not align with the operation of Direction 110. 

The court explained that para 5.2(2): 

  • addressed the Australian community’s safety from the risk of physical or other harm from a non-citizen’s criminal or other serious conduct, which was the federal government’s “highest priority” and which was part of the decision-makers’ framework when approaching “their task of deciding whether to refuse or cancel a non-citizen's visa under section 501” of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) 
  • aimed to help the decision-maker assign weight to the potentially competing primary considerations in paras 8.1–8.5 
  • did not require the decision-maker to consider each possibly competing primary consideration in those paragraphs, except in line with its own terms 

Reasonableness of the decision

The High Court disagreed with the plaintiff’s assertion that the delegate’s decision was legally unreasonable. The court held that the plaintiff based his argument on the same misinterpretation of Direction 110’s requirements. 

According to Direction 110’s requirements, the court decided that the delegate had logically and reasonably determined that granting the plaintiff a visa and letting him return to Australia would amount to an unacceptable risk of harm to the Australian community, specifically the risk that he would harm his own family through criminal conduct involving family violence. 

Child’s best interests

Given the best interests of the plaintiff’s daughter, the High Court could not infer that the delegate failed to consider that the plaintiff's continued absence from Australia would negatively impact his wife’s capacity to care for their family. 

The court pointed out that the delegate had found that the daughter’s best interests strongly favoured family reunification. 

More High Court cases

On 10 June 2026, the High Court of Australia ruled that the Commonwealth and its officers had no defence against liability for the tort of false imprisonment relating to a plaintiff’s immigration detention between 28 July 2022 and 8 November 2023. 

On 22 April 2026, a High Court justice granted leave for Maddocks to withdraw as the applicant’s solicitors and for the respondent minister for immigration, citizenship, migrant services, and multicultural affairs to file a bill of costs in this proceeding. 

Enjoy this story? Read the latest litigation and dispute resolution news on the main page!