High Court orders retrial of abuse case against foster father’s estate

Proceedings arose from a couple’s temporary care of a ward of the state

High Court orders retrial of abuse case against foster father’s estate
High Court of Australia

Australia’s High Court has ordered the retrial of proceedings between a then-ward of the state of New South Wales and the estate of her foster father, who had been convicted in 2019 of offences in connection with sexually abusing her. 

The case was Estate of Croft v MTH [2026] HCA 44. In February 1979, when she was 16 years old, MTH entered into temporary foster care with a married couple. 

NSW Supreme Court proceedings

In 2020, before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, MTH asked for damages for assault from her short-term foster father. MTH also requested damages for negligence from the state of NSW and her short-term foster mother. 

Before the hearing, the foster father passed away. His estate took over as a defendant in the proceedings. While acknowledging that he had been convicted of offences against MTH, the estate denied that he had physically or sexually abused her. 

In 2024, Justice Cavanagh of the NSW Supreme Court assumed that s 91(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) precluded the use of the evidence of the convictions as evidence of the abuse. 

Given his assessment of MTH’s credit, the primary judge dismissed MTH’s claim against the estate upon determining that the foster father had not abused her. 

Case before NSW Court of Appeal

MTH appealed from Justice Cavanagh’s rejection of her claims against her foster father’s estate, her foster mother, and the state of NSW. 

In 2025, the New South Wales Court of Appeal granted MTH’s appeal and substituted a judgment ordering the estate to pay her damages in the assessed amount. The appeal court ruled that the primary judge erred by: 

  • assuming that MTH was not relying on the foster father's convictions to prove the abuse 
  • misunderstanding the impact of the exception to s 91(1), as found in s 92(2) of the Evidence Act 
  • failing to weigh the evidence of the convictions on the assumption that there had been the tender of a certificate under s 178 of the Evidence Act that was “prima facie” evidence of the abuse 
  • denying procedural fairness by not informing her about the evidentiary pathway enabling her to establish the commission of the offences by tendering a s 178 certificate 

Contrary to the primary judge’s findings, the appeal court accepted MTH’s evidence of the abuse and most of her evidence about its effects. The appeal court proceeded “as if” there had been the tender of a s 178 certificate at first instance. 

Otherwise, the appeal court dismissed MTH’s appeal against the denial of her claims against the foster mother and the state. 

High Court’s orders

With special leave, the foster father’s estate appealed from the portion of the appeal court’s judgment affirming MTH’s claim against it.

The High Court partly allowed the appeal and set aside the NSW Court of Appeal’s 6 June 2025 orders numbered (3) and (5). 

In place of those orders, the High Court set aside Justice Cavanagh’s 28 November 2024 orders numbered (2) and (4) and his 18 December 2024 order numbered (1) in relation to the second defendant’s costs. 

The High Court directed the appellant to pay the amici curiae’s costs. Otherwise, the High Court dismissed the appeal. 

High Court’s findings

The High Court held that the NSW Court of Appeal correctly determined that Justice Cavanagh erred in: 

  • assuming that MTH was not relying on evidence of the convictions as evidence of the abuse she claimed on the part of her foster father 
  • disregarding evidence of the foster father’s convictions as evidence of such abuse 

The High Court found the convictions admissible as proof of a disputed fact in the proceedings leading to the convictions because the evidence satisfied the exception to s 91(1) of the Evidence Act, as provided by s 92(2). 

The High Court added that the failure to consider the evidence of the convictions materially affected the primary judge’s determination of MTH’s case against the estate, including his assessment of her credibility as a witness. 

Errors identified

The High Court decided that the NSW Court of Appeal erred in: 

  • resolving the appeal “as if” there had been the tender of a conviction certificate when there was no such tender before the primary judge or the appeal court 
  • accepting MTH’s evidence about the alleged abuse and its impacts without properly considering the weight to be attached to the evidence of the convictions and without weighing all the evidence in the context of that consideration 

More High Court cases

On 9 September 2026, the High Court of Australia found no basis to reopen its 5 November 2025 judgment, which agreed with a firm of solicitors that an appellate court had erred in upholding and remitting an ex-husband’s claim for further compensatory damages. 

In property proceedings under s 79 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) (FLA), the High Court issued a December 2025 ruling denying writs of certiorari quashing three orders of a judge of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, Division 1. 

Enjoy this story? Read the latest litigation and dispute resolution news on the main page!