Ruling finds pre-2019 law authorised companies to reveal whistleblower’s identity to lawyers
The Supreme Court of Queensland held that pre-2019 laws implicitly allowed companies to name whistleblowers to their lawyers, upholding Shell’s legal privilege claims.
In Quinlan v Shell Energy Operations Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] QSC 265, handed down on 11 November 2026, the court dismissed a former employee’s bid to access 68 documents that Shell Energy Operations, formerly ERM Power, claimed were covered by legal professional privilege.
The employee, who worked at ERM from 2008 to 2014, claimed that he made whistleblower disclosures to directors and officers between May 2012 and July 2014. He alleged that he suffered retaliation because some of the defendants improperly revealed details of those disclosures.
Fifty of the documents identified him as a whistleblower. He argued that the communications breached, or furthered breaches of, the confidentiality offence in s. 1317AE of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) as it stood before 1 July 2019. He said the crime/fraud exception, which removes protection from communications that further a crime or fraud, therefore stripped the documents of privilege.
At the hearing, his counsel narrowed the argument, accepting that the old law may have implicitly authorised disclosure to lawyers where naming the whistleblower was “essential” to obtaining “proper legal advice”.
The court went further, holding that s. 1317AE implicitly authorised ERM to reveal to its lawyers the whistleblower’s identity and the information he disclosed, without any requirement that the disclosure be “essential”. It found it highly unlikely that Parliament intended the offence to strip a company of its right to “full and unreserved communication” with its lawyers.
The court said that lawyers’ duty of confidence kept such disclosure consistent with the offence’s protective purposes. It found that legal advice promoted the regime’s aims, including resolving matters internally. The crime/fraud exception would still apply if a company consulted lawyers for some “nefarious purpose” rather than for advice. Since 1 July 2019, the Act has expressly authorised disclosure to lawyers for advice about the regime.
Shell could not produce evidence from anyone with first-hand knowledge of the documents, as Queensland’s court rules require. The former employee did not oppose inspection. The court inspected all 68 documents, citing the time elapsed, Shell’s takeover of ERM, self-incrimination claims by some authors or recipients who were defendants and Shell’s reasonable steps to find others with first-hand knowledge.
It found that privilege attached to the documents and that the crime/fraud exception applied to none. The court also rejected a challenge to the independence of ERM’s group general counsel, finding that his advice reflected his role as the company’s lawyer only.
The court said it would hear the parties on costs and on Shell’s application concerning inadvertent disclosure of privileged material.