Ruling finds a two-thirds noteholder majority can accept new first-ranking security
The NSW Supreme Court has found that Zen Energy needed only majority lender approval, not unanimous consent, to grant new security ranking ahead of existing noteholders.
In Old Treasury (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Zen Energy Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) [2026] NSWSC 1455, handed down on 16 November 2026, the court dismissed a challenge by two noteholders (together, Old Treasury), which had lent $4.5 million under Zen Energy’s $160 million loan note facility.
In October 2025, Zen Energy sought noteholder approval for a super senior facility of up to $66.1 million. Old Treasury argued that every noteholder had to agree. Holders of 93.9 percent of the notes consented, and a priority deed ranked the new security first. Zen Energy entered voluntary administration in July 2026 and liquidation in August.
Old Treasury sought declarations that the new security breached the 2023 loan note deed’s negative pledge, a promise not to grant competing security, and could not take priority. It relied on a clause requiring each affected lender’s consent to any amendment or waiver changing “the priority or order of payment” against it.
The court held that accepting security under the deed’s terms did not amend the deed. “The exercise of an existing power does not, merely because it affects the parties’ respective positions, amend the provision conferring it,” the court said. It added that “priority” in the clause meant priority of payment, which had not changed. The priority deed, not any amendment, gave the new facility first rank.
The deed permitted security if Zen Energy or a guarantor disclosed it to lenders holding at least two-thirds of the debt and they accepted it. Old Treasury argued that this exception covered only security approved before the first drawdown. The court found that the clause looked forward, and that acceptance needed only to precede the security’s creation. On Old Treasury’s reading, it noted, the ban on new security would become absolute after the first drawdown.
The court distinguished the “uptier” transaction in the US case In Re Serta Simmons Bedding LLC, as the lenders here provided new money rather than swapping existing debt for higher-ranking debt. It added that if a majority used the power purely to gain priority over a minority, “questions of proper purpose would likely arise.”
In any event, the court said that it would have refused declarations on priority and on sharing credit bid proceeds. The 2023 facility’s security trustee held the security and had signed the priority deed, which Old Treasury had not sought to set aside. Nor could Old Treasury enforce sharing provisions in subscription agreements to which it was not a party. The court ordered Old Treasury to pay the super senior security trustee’s costs of the proceedings.