Review makes 17 recommendations to address accountability and court pressures
The Ministry of Justice has pledged to implement 17 recommendations from a Performance Improvement Review (PIR) that identified leadership, accountability, and organisational culture problems, alongside growing pressures on the country’s justice system.
The Public Service Commission released the review following concerns about the ministry’s handling of the Russell Harrison employment matter. The review examined broader operational and organisational challenges rather than the merits of individual employment decisions.
Secretary for Justice Andrew Kibblewhite accepted the findings and committed to implementing the recommendations.
“The Review concludes that the way we work currently is not sustainable and I agree. As chief executive I accept the findings and I will ensure the recommendations are implemented,” Kibblewhite said in a statement.
The review found that the ministry’s handling of Harrison’s prolonged suspension illustrated wider problems involving risk avoidance, unclear decision-making responsibilities, and insufficient challenges to internal advice. Harrison remained suspended on full pay for five years before his employment ended in June 2026.
Reviewers also identified a hierarchical organisational culture that discouraged staff from challenging decisions and limited opportunities for innovation. They recommended strengthening leadership accountability, reviewing organisational values, and clarifying the ministry’s approach to risk.
The review acknowledged improvements in court backlogs and timeliness but found that increasing case complexity, workforce constraints, and fiscal pressures made existing operating arrangements unsustainable.
It called for a clearer long-term strategy and closer collaboration with the judiciary to improve court administration while protecting judicial independence.
The ministry has begun implementing changes, including Te Au Reka, a digital caseflow management system designed to modernise court administration. Implementation in the family court begins on 23 November.
The ministry is also developing reforms through its “Accessible and Affordable Justice” programme.
Kibblewhite said the ministry was revising its business plan to prioritise the recommendations and would regularly update ministers, the Public Service Commission, the judiciary, and sector partners on implementation progress.