Supreme Court denies leave to appeal in Oranga Tamariki proceedings

Leave claimant asked the Family Court to make a parenting order and discharge a custody order

Supreme Court denies leave to appeal in Oranga Tamariki proceedings
Supreme Court of New Zealand

The New Zealand Supreme Court dismissed an application for leave to appeal in proceedings arising from decisions of Oranga Tamariki – Ministry for Children in connection with the care of the applicant’s daughter. 

Before the Family Court, the applicant in Vickers v Chief Executive of Oranga Tamariki - Ministry for Children [2026] NZSC 176 applied to discharge a custody order over his young daughter and to make a parenting order in his favour. 

High Court judgments

Before the High Court, the applicant applied for a judicial review of the respondent ministry’s decisions. He raised the same issues as he did in the Family Court matter. 

On 1 December 2025, the High Court stayed the judicial review proceedings pending the Family Court’s decision. 

After the Family Court denied his applications, the applicant asked the High Court for leave to appeal against the Family Court judgment. 

On 18 December 2025, the High Court declined leave. On 29 January 2026, the High Court awarded the applicant costs relating to its judgments granting a stay and denying leave. 

Court of Appeal proceedings

Before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, the applicant applied for leave to appeal from the High Court of New Zealand’s three prior judgments. 

On 12 June 2026, the appeal court denied the applicant’s leave applications and awarded costs to the respondent ministry. 

Supreme Court denies leave application

Before the Supreme Court, the applicant pursued leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal’s decision. 

The registrar refused to accept the leave application for filing upon determining that the Supreme Court lacked jurisdiction under s 68(b) of the Senior Courts Act 2016. 

The applicant applied for a review of the registrar’s decision. This review application partly succeeded because the Supreme Court might have jurisdiction over an appeal from the appeal court’s costs award. 

In refusing leave to appeal, the Supreme Court ordered the applicant to pay the respondent ministry $4,850 in costs. 

Supreme Court’s analysis

The Supreme Court acknowledged that it might have jurisdiction over the appeal if it treated the costs award as a decision distinct from the appeal court’s leave decision. 

However, even if there was such jurisdiction, the Supreme Court ruled that the applicant did not meet the requirements for granting leave to appeal. 

In connection with the costs award, the Supreme Court saw no issue of general or public importance and no miscarriage of justice in the civil context. 

“Here the award was made to the successful party on a standard basis,” the Supreme Court stated. 

The Supreme Court awarded the respondent standard costs for opposing an application for leave to appeal. 

More Supreme Court cases

In a case involving a barrister and solicitor found guilty of misconduct under s 7 of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006, the Supreme Court of New Zealand made a 29 October 2026 decision declining to extend the stay of his suspension to 29 January 2027. 

In proceedings arising from a claim that a law firm provided negligent legal work, the Supreme Court issued a 27 October 2026 ruling denying leave to appeal against the judicial conduct commissioner’s decision in favour of the judges who ruled on two recall applications. 

Enjoy this story? Read the latest litigation and dispute resolution news on the main page!