Supreme Court affirms rejection of habeas corpus request

Prior Supreme Court ruling found a proposed appeal moot in similar circumstances

Supreme Court affirms rejection of habeas corpus request
Supreme Court of New Zealand

In habeas corpus proceedings arising from a District Court’s 22 October 2026 decision granting the applicant bail, the New Zealand Supreme Court dismissed his application for leave to appeal and his interlocutory application dated 2 November 2026. 

In H (SC 115/2026) v Chief Executive of the Department of Corrections [2026] NZSC 173, the applicant applied for habeas corpus. 

The first respondent in this case was the chief executive of the Department of Corrections, while the second respondent was the police commissioner. 

High Court, Court of Appeal proceedings

In a minute, the High Court ordered a hearing of the matter through an audio link. The High Court declined the habeas corpus application, describing it as an impermissible challenge against the District Court’s bail decision. 

Before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, the applicant appealed against the High Court of New Zealand’s minute and its denial of the habeas corpus application. 

The appeal court dismissed the appeal. On 22 October 2026, the applicant applied for leave to appeal from the appeal court’s decision. 

Memoranda with parties’ positions

Through a memorandum dated 30 October 2026, the first respondent’s counsel cited Crequer v Chief Executive of Department of Corrections [2010] NZSC 48. 

In that judgment, the Supreme Court determined that a proposed appeal was moot given the applicant’s release on bail and that s 14(2)(b) of the Habeas Corpus Act 2001 prevented a court from questioning a decision on bail. 

Via a memorandum dated 2 November 2026, the applicant disagreed with counsel’s position and argued that the Crequer decision was distinguishable. 

By an interlocutory application filed on 2 November 2026, the applicant requested the release of certain material to help the Supreme Court rule on the leave application. 

Supreme Court denies leave to appeal

In declining leave to appeal, the Supreme Court ordered the applicant to pay the first respondent $2,425 in costs. 

Considering the Crequer ruling indistinguishable, the Supreme Court held that s 14(2)(b) of the Habeas Corpus Act 2001 barred the appeal. The Supreme Court rejected the applicant’s argument in her memorandum. 

“The fact that the application for leave to appeal was filed on the same day that the applicant was granted bail (presumably following her release from custody) is immaterial,” the Supreme Court stated. “There is no jurisdiction to grant habeas corpus when the applicant is not detained.” 

Given these findings, the Supreme Court deemed it appropriate to reject the interlocutory application as well. 

Other Supreme Court cases

On 10 November 2026, the Supreme Court of New Zealand denied a periodontist’s request for leave to appeal following his unsuccessful attempts to secure name suppression in disciplinary proceedings arising from the treatment he provided during the COVID-19 lockdown in Auckland. 

In striking out an application for leave to appeal in a habeas corpus matter, the Supreme Court issued a 2 October 2026 ruling finding no reason for a law firm that was not a party to the previous proceedings to be a party before it. 

Enjoy this story? Read the latest litigation and dispute resolution news on the main page!