High Court: Equal Pay Act changes ‘inconsistent’ with Bill of Rights

Court ruled that amendments impacted the right to freedom from discrimination on the basis of sex

High Court: Equal Pay Act changes ‘inconsistent’ with Bill of Rights

The High Court in Wellington has declared that changes made to the Equal Pay Act 1972 under the Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 are legislatively inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act.

In a ruling published on Thursday 19 November, justice Paul Radich determined that the Equal Pay Act amendments did not align with s.19 of the Bill of Rights Act, which enshrined into law the right to freedom from discrimination on the grounds of sex.

The legal challenge against the attorney-general was made by five unions: Tōpūtanga Tapuhi Kaitiaki O Aotearoa | The New Zealand Nurses Organisation Incorporation, New Zealand Public Service Association | Te Pukenga Here Tikanga Mahi Incorporated, New Zealand Post-Primary Teachers Association Incorporated, New Zealand Teritary Education Union | Te Hautu Kahurangi O Aotearoa Incorporated, and New Zealand Educational Institute | Te Riu Roa Incorporated. They claimed that their members experienced pay inequity in their occupations.

Equal Pay Act reforms were unanimously passed in 2017 that incorporated provisions to determine pay equity claims into the law. Last year, the Act was quickly modified over a two-day period.

The court noted the following key amendments to the statutory scheme:

  • all existing pay equity claims were terminated immediately
  • the threshold of “female dominated” workplaces was increased from 60% to 70% for the past decade, which precluded previously available claims from being re-filed
  • pay equity issues were restricted from identification and handling for 10 years after a pay equity settlement
  • comparator use outside a claimant group’s industry or sector was barred
  • evidence of merit had to be provided at the outset
  • employers could cut off pay equity claims
  • employers in multi-employer claims could opt out without having to provide justification

According to the applicants, the provisions violated s.19 of the Bill of Rights Act instead of enabling pay equity claims. Moreover, the manner in which the 2025 reforms were introduced constituted a Bill of Rights Act breach as well.

The High Court agreed with the unions that the reformed Equal Pay Act discriminated on the grounds of sex. It found that the discrimination was not justified under s.5 of the Bill of Rights Act.

The court ruled that as it currently was, the Equal Pay Act did not treat women in female-dominated workplaces the same as it did people in gender-balanced or male-dominated workplaces. It decided the reforms to the law resulted in “material disadvantage” without a “sufficiently important purpose”. The pay equity-related restrictions were also not “rationally connected” with the law’s purpose, did not limit the right more than reasonable necessary, and were not “in due proportion to the importance of the measure’s objective”, the court said in a summary of the judgment.

Nonetheless, the court concluded that the urgent enactment of the Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 without consultation or notice was not unlawful or in violation of s.27(1) and (3) of the rights legislation. Moreover, the changes were not inconsistent with the rights to natural justice and to bring civil proceedings.

The court ultimately decided it must exercise its discretion to issue a declaration of inconsistency with s.19 of the Bill of Rights Act after determining that the section could cover the right to freedom from pay inequity. It determined that such a declaration was appropriate to acknowledge the rights of the women represented by the unions and the violation of these rights.

Radich ruled that the unions were entitled to costs and allowed the parties to discuss them “in the first instance”, urging them to “do so purposefully in order to arrive at a mutually acceptable outcome”. He instructed the unions to file a memorandum within 20 working days of 19 November if the parties could not agree on costs; the attorney-general could respond with any memorandum within another 10 working days.

He said the memoranda should not exceed seven pages, including schedules.

The hearing on the matter took place over 4-6 August. The unions were represented by R E Harrison KC, P Cranney and K Neo of Oakley Moran in Wellington; U R Jagose KC, K E E Whiting and S Cvitanovich of Wellington’s Crown Law Office acted for the attorney-general.

The Human Rights Commission was represented by R A Kirkness KC, H Z Yang and A J Campbell.