Highlight: Employers must be mindful when citing redundancy as a reason for dismissal

Redundancies that are not genuine can fall under unfair dismissal

Highlight: Employers must be mindful when citing redundancy as a reason for dismissal

When COVID-19 first hit, many organisations tightened their belts by implementing salary cuts, furloughs and layoffs. Redundancy became one of the reasons why an employee could be let go. Nonetheless, employers also need to be careful or they can find themselves in hot water for unfair dismissal.

“A position will only be genuinely redundant if the employer no longer requires the job (i.e., the particular collection of duties, functions and responsibilities) to be performed by anyone,” Holding Redlich partner Andrew Klein told Australasian Lawyer.

“Importantly, it is also, more often than not, a requirement for a redundancy to be genuine that the relevant employee and, if applicable, their representatives, are consulted before a final decision regarding a redundancy is made.”

Before letting an employee go for redundancy, employers are obliged to determine whether redeployment to a new role is possible. Moreover, a redundancy that is not found to be genuine is considered unfair dismissal, he added.

Under the Fair Work Act 2009, unfair dismissal occurs when the termination of a worker is judged by the Fair Work Commission to be “harsh, unjust or unreasonable.” A dismissal may be “harsh” if it is an extreme or disproportionate response to an incident.

A dismissal is “unjust” if the worker is found to be innocent in the matter they were dismissed over, while it is “unreasonable” if evidence is lacking to support the reason behind the dismissal.

In addition to having a valid reason for the dismissal, the employee must have been notified and given a chance to respond. The commission also looks into whether the employee was unreasonably refused a support person during dismissal meetings, and takes the employee’s personal circumstances into account.

Recent articles & video

MinterEllison lawyers set to help JWS launch in Canberra

mx51's $32.5m capital raise succeeds with HWL Ebsworth's help

Research finds hourly rates have gone above and beyond the GHR

What are organizations doing to manage turnover?

Are masking policies still valid?

Ex-Lendlease IR head pumps up Lander & Rogers' workplace relations practice

Most Read Articles

Ex-Lendlease IR head pumps up Lander & Rogers' workplace relations practice

Macpherson Kelley board gets marketing lift with new advisory board addition

SPB, Thomson Geer confirm roles in $350m off-market takeover bid

NRF admits new partner from DLA Piper