Bell Gully scores major tax-avoidance win in the High Court

The case is a rare victory for a taxpayer facing tax-avoidance allegations

Bell Gully scores major tax-avoidance win in the High Court

Bell Gully has helped score a rare win for a taxpayer facing tax-avoidance allegations in New Zealand.

The firm represented Frucor Suntory New Zealand in Frucor Suntory New Zealand Limited v Commissioner of Inland Revenue. The firm said that the High Court’s decision in the case will have far-reaching effects on future tax-avoidance cases.

The firm and barrister Lindsay McKay successfully struck down the claim that Frucor Suntory avoided paying taxes by using convertible note financing to fund its New Zealand business.

Most Read

“In recent years taxpayers have had limited success in resisting tax-avoidance allegations, and this decision may be the first step in rebalancing the position,” Bell Gully said.

Partner Mathew McKay, who acted on the matter, said Justice Matthew Muir’s judgment is “logical and insightful” and is “founded on a firm understanding of the relevant tax principles.” He said that High Court’s decision is a reminder to the IRD that tax-avoidance allegations must be based on “rational argument that pays attention to existing policy and legislative design.”

Bell Gully said that the judgement “accepts that Parliament would have contemplated that tax​payers would ordinarily be entitled to interest deductions on debt instruments, if set at an arm’s-length rate.”

It also “confirms that the presence of unorthodox features in an internal arrangement between group companies will not necessarily be regarded as ‘artificial’ features in a tax-avoidance analysis – it is the tax outcomes that must be considered,” the firm said.

The judgment “reinforces the traditional separate legal entity approach in an international tax context” as well as “provides an indication that shortfall penalties will not automatically follow a finding of tax avoidance.”

Related stories

Free newsletter

Subscribe to our FREE newsletter service and we’ll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Please enter your email address below and click on Sign Up for daily newsletters from NZ Lawyer.

Recent articles & video

Litigation partner trades Martelli McKegg for Princes Chambers

Microsoft taps Simpson Grierson for advice on NZ data centre setup

Energy experts trade one global firm for another

Chapman Tripp names new chief executive partner

NZ’s first new retail green bond issue for 2020 blooms with Chapman Tripp’s help

Family law-specialist barrister appointed as new district court judge

Most Read Articles

Duncan Cotterill appoints new chair of partnership and board

NZ Law Awards finalists revealed

Chapman Tripp names new chief executive partner

MinterEllisonRuddWatts senior associate gleans valuable lessons about flexible work from lockdown