Judge accepts testator initially planned to make separate wills for US and non-US property
Accepting evidence that a will-maker originally intended to prepare distinct wills for his property within and outside the US, the New Zealand High Court ordered the correction of his last will by removing the contradictory words from its introduction.
In Estate of Davis [2026] NZHC 3471, New Zealand was the domicile of the testator, who owned property in New Zealand and in the US. Mr K received instructions from him in or about 2019 and prepared the testamentary documents.
In July 2019, Mr K emailed the testator two draft wills: one dealing with his US property and another disposing of his non-US property. Mr K recommended asking a lawyer familiar with US law to review the draft pertaining to the testator’s US property.
The testator executed his last will on 24 January 2020. According to the introductory provision, the will would apply to all the testator’s property “other than in the United States of America.”
However, the will’s dispositive provisions sought to:
The testator passed away in Bali on or about 5 August 2026.
As the testator’s widow and the executor designated in his last will, the applicant sought:
The applicant alleged that admitting and administering the last will without the requested correction would risk the failure of its dispositions and a partial intestacy of her deceased husband’s property.
In the circumstances, the High Court issued leave for the testator’s widow to make her application without notice to anyone else. According to the court, requiring notice would duplicate the notification already given and would add undue delay.
The High Court took issue with Mr K’s dual roles as counsel and witness in this application.
“I am satisfied, however, that the application in this case is uncontentious and involves the straightforward correction of an obvious and explicable clerical error,” wrote Justice Wilkinson-Smith. “I do not wish to create additional expense and delay by insisting that the application is refiled by a solicitor who is not also a witness.”
The High Court directed the correction of the last will by deleting the following words from its introductory provision: “other than in the United States of America.”
The court acknowledged the drafting error leading to an inconsistency between the last will’s introduction and its dispositive provisions.
The court explained that the last will’s introductory passage, which would exclude the US property of the deceased:
Acknowledging the breakdown of the relationship between two siblings who were co-executors of their father’s estate, the High Court issued an 8 September 2026 ruling discharging one brother under s 21 of the Administration Act 1969.
In an estate dispute between siblings, the High Court of New Zealand issued an 8 July 2026 order requiring the brother to vacate and give up possession of the property where he was residing to his sister as administrator of the estate of their late father.
Enjoy this story? Read the latest litigation and dispute resolution news on the main page!