The committee censured a lawyer for his inappropriate comments to a student
A New Zealand Law Society | Te Kāhui Ture o Aotearoa standards committee has reminded lawyers to act professional around law students after one seasoned practitioner made inappropriate comments to a student.
The student, referred to as Ms L, was a participant in an observation programme for final year law students. During the course of the programme, she attended proceedings in court and used its facilities.
While at a courthouse for one such activity, she was taking her lunch alone in a lawyers’ room when the veteran lawyer, who was given the moniker Mr J, came in and struck up a conversation. He asked about Ms L’s employment plans and she voiced worries about the availability of graduate roles. He shared options and possible opportunities, and in the process remarked about sexual act graduates could perform to secure jobs. The conversation concluded with the entrance of another lawyer into the room.
Subsequently, Ms L disclosed Mr J’s comments to a lawyer who proceeded to file a complaint with the Law Society.
The committee referred to the case of National Standards Committee No 2 v MR ZKA [2025] NZLCDT 18, where a disciplinary tribunal ruled that social and informal interactions in workplace settings may be construed as being under “regulated services”. The committee pointed out that Ms L and Mr J’s conversation took place in a professional environment, with Mr J acting as a practising lawyer engaging in a discussion about employment in the legal profession. Thus, the conversation was related to the provision of regulated services and was covered by the professional conduct obligation under the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006 (LCA).
However, Mr J argued that his conduct did not constitute a violation of the LCA (Lawyers: Conduct and Client Care) Rules 2008 (RCCC). He claimed that his comments were an “ill-judged and crass attempt at humour rather than a serious or deliberate statement”.
The committee countered that his comments did not align with the maintenance of professional standards as mandated by RCCC rule 10. It said his statement weakened the professional setting’s dignity and the standards to which lawyers are held.
Moreover, the committee noted that Mr J was obligated to show respect and courtesy in his treatment of all persons – a quality his comments failed to display. The committee said his comments could suggest that offering sexual favours to obtain employment was a tolerated practice, which would damage the profession’s reputation.
The committee added that it was a one-on-one conversation where there was an experience gap between Mr J and Ms L. Thus, it determined that Mr J violated rules 10.1 and 10.2 of the RCCC.
The power imbalance also factored into the committee’s judgment that Mr J breached rule 10.3 of the RCCC because his comments fell under the definition of sexual harassment. It noted that the remarks were “plainly” sexual and were likely offensive or unwelcome given the context in which he made them.
A legal complaints review officer had previously stressed that inappropriate comments to junior lawyers reflected a “troubling lack of judgement and a failure to maintain appropriate professional boundaries”, explaining that lawyers were to be especially mindful of being professional in interactions with new entrants to the profession. With this in mind, the committee determined that Mr J’s conduct was “significantly below the required standards”. Thus, his behaviour was considered unsatisfactory conduct under sections 12(b) and (c) of the LCA.
Ultimately, the committee decided to censure Mr J and fine him $1,500. It also ordered him to pay costs and issue an apology to Ms L.
The committee also required Mr J to finish courses on sexual harassment in the workplace and on bullying and harassment for managers and leaders.