Judge disqualifies himself from ‘rubbish’ trial

A judge who called a plaintiff’s claim ‘rubbish’ has granted an application to disqualify himself.

Judge disqualifies himself from ‘rubbish’ trial
A Southport judge has disqualified himself from a trial after he called the plaintiff’s case ‘rubbish’ and ‘a disgrace’.

“The case is a never-ending story as far as the plaintiff’s side is concerned,” Judge Clive Wall said.

Wall then ordered a new trial following a complaint by the plaintiff about 11 comments he made, made after nearly a week of hearings.  According to the Courier Mail, Wall said his remarks were made out of extreme frustration.

The claim is against executors of an estate, arising out of a fractured relationship between family members.

“I have not seen, in almost 20 years on the bench, a more concerning case than this,” Wall said during the hearing.

He also said, “This type of case brings the legal profession into gross disrepute”, and in his decision he said he maintained that view.

Wall granted the plaintiff’s application for the judge to disqualify himself from the case.

“The trial has reached its seventh day, unfortunately. It should never have gone for this long,” he said before disqualifying himself.

“If any blame is to be attributed to its duration, it is, in my view, the plaintiff’s and not the defendants.

“I consider I have no option but to disqualify myself,” he said.

Free newsletter

Subscribe to our FREE newsletter service and we’ll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Please enter your email address below and click on Sign Up for daily newsletters from Australasian Lawyer.

Recent articles & video

$570m acquisition succeeds with Lander & Rogers' advice

NRF helps clinch EPC contract for Victorian solar farm

HWL Ebsworth advises in acquisition of 16 Melbourne paint businesses

US state says non-compete for in-house lawyers unethical

Global firm adopts "holistic approach" to client service…

Eight law firms among top 100 employers Australian graduates seek

Most Read Articles

Adelaide lawyer wins $750k defamation judgment over Google review

Eight law firms among top 100 employers Australian graduates seek

Two top-tier firms act as Federal Court clears $15bn Vodafone-TPG merger

Clyde & Co scores three partners from global firm