Why the latest High Court judgment on Southern Response is ‘extremely important’

Peter Woods, Anthony Harper litigation partner, explains what the result means for affected homeowners

Why the latest High Court judgment on Southern Response is ‘extremely important’

The High Court has found that Southern Response behaved deceptively in a case that a leading litigation lawyer said has far-reaching effects.

Justice David Gendall said in a judgment handed down Friday that the Crown-owned earthquake claims company was disingenuous in the way it presented the entitlements through a document called a Detailed Rebuild Assessment (DRA) for Karl and Alison Dodds’ earthquake-damaged home.

“Editing or redacting parts of such an important assessment document, and then suggesting it is the complete and only assessment of total rebuild cost as occurred here, is misleading and deceptive,” the judgment said.

Most Read

Peter Woods, the Anthony Harper litigation partner who represented the Doddses in the case, explained why the judgment is significant.

“This is an extremely important result, not just for the Dodds, but for up to approximately 3,000 homeowners who settled their insurance claims with Southern Response, based on the Detailed Rebuild Assessment supplied by Arrow for Southern Response,” he said.

The Doddses were awarded $178,894.30, plus interest and costs.

“Southern Response, at a senior management level, decided to exclude costs from the DRAs supplied to homeowners. That decision meant that homeowners were misled into believing that the DRA was an accurate assessment of the cost to rebuild their homes. That decision meant that potentially thousands of homeowners were paid less than Southern Response calculated it would cost to rebuild their homes,” Woods said.

Taxpayers could be on the hook for hundreds of millions of dollars because of the practice, according to an estimate by Southern Response, he said.

Peter Woods

Related stories

Free newsletter

Subscribe to our FREE newsletter service and we’ll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Please enter your email address below and click on Sign Up for daily newsletters from NZ Lawyer.

Recent articles & video

Two more experienced lawyers join Juno Legal

Last call for Innovative Firms 2020

New Criminal Cases Review Commission leaders sought

Sidley Austin appoints chief diversity officer

A&O appoints regional diversity and inclusion partners…

In-house legal teams need to take more risks says report…

Most Read Articles

Simpson Grierson elevates three to partner

Commercial law expert makes partner at Lowndes Jordan

Six firms among NZ’s most sought-after employers

Two more experienced lawyers join Juno Legal