Police cite insufficient evidence after investigation, but three women will pursue civil claims
Victoria Police will not lay criminal charges against four Australian Football League (AFL) players following an investigation into sexual assault allegations at Melbourne’s Pullman Hotel, citing insufficient evidence.
The Australian reported that Sydney Swans players Isaac Heeney, Chad Warner, and James Jordon, alongside North Melbourne recruit Nick Blakey, faced allegations from three women who claimed the players inappropriately touched and slapped them at the hotel on 17 August 2026.
Police announced their decision almost three months after the alleged incident, saying a thorough investigation and legal advice led them to conclude there was insufficient evidence to proceed with criminal charges.
All four players have maintained their innocence.
The Sydney Swans previously stood down the players for the remainder of the season after finding they breached club behaviour standards by drinking, staying out late, and inviting the women to their hotel. The club also stood down Riley Bice, whom police later treated as a witness and cleared of wrongdoing.
The Swans maintained that their disciplinary decision remained separate from the criminal investigation and announced a comprehensive review of their AFL program.
Despite the police decision, the three women intend to pursue civil proceedings, according to The Australian.
Slater and Gordon senior lawyer Jackson Pannam, representing one complainant, said his client was devastated by the outcome.
“The decision by Victoria Police does not amount to a finding that the incident our client reported did not occur, nor does it diminish the seriousness of what she says happened or its profound impact on her,” Pannam said.
He emphasised the different standards of proof governing criminal and civil proceedings. Criminal prosecutions require proof beyond reasonable doubt, while civil courts determine claims on the balance of probabilities.
Pannam confirmed that Slater and Gordon would continue preparing a civil claim against the relevant parties.
John Karantzis of Carbone Lawyers, representing the other two women, also confirmed their intention to proceed with civil action.
Heeney, who lost his vice-captaincy following the incident, thanked his family, fiancée, and club supporters in a statement following the police announcement.
Blakey joined North Melbourne on 12 October under an eight-year contract reportedly worth more than $11 million.
The police investigation has concluded, but the proposed civil proceedings remain outstanding.