UK government position on Brexit legislation met with criticism

“This really is first-term, first-year undergraduate tosh from the attorney general,” a legal commentator says

UK government position on Brexit legislation met with criticism

The UK government has issued a statement on its legal position on the UK Internal Market Bill—a position that has been criticised by many, according to the Law Society Gazette.

The bill, which was published on Wednesday, was intended to “promote the continued functioning of the internal market in the UK after the conclusion of the transition period provided for in the Withdrawal Agreement and the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018,” the government said in its statement. In the process, the proposed legislation would violate international law, particularly in Northern Ireland’s case.

The Law Society of England and Wales opposed the proposed legislation, and said that the rule of law was non-negotiable.

Most Read

However, the government argued that in implementing the legislation would not be an unconstitutional act by Parliament, saying that in the current landscape, it was “important to remember the fundamental principle of parliamentary sovereignty.”

“Parliament is sovereign as a matter of domestic law and can pass legislation which is in breach of the UK’s treaty obligations,” the government said in its statement.

The position was slammed by legal experts.

“This really is first-term, first-year undergraduate tosh from the attorney general,” said David Allen Green, a legal commentator.

Meanwhile, University of Cambridge public law professor Mark Elliott said that the government’s position was laughable.

“The government’s argument is that parliament’s legal capacity in domestic law to make any law it wants somehow makes it acceptable, as a matter of international law, for the UK to renege on its treaty obligations. But the latter does not follow the former,” he said.

Related stories

Free newsletter

Subscribe to our FREE newsletter service and we’ll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Please enter your email address below and click on Sign Up for daily newsletters from Australasian Lawyer.

Recent articles & video

Moray & Agnew adds personal injury team to Sydney office

Norton Rose Fulbright expands government disputes practice with key hires

UK legal services firm suspends barrister for controversial Sussex baby tweet

Baker McKenzie’s Australia ECM head: ‘Are you OK?’ is critical to mental health support

Lander & Rogers welcomes renowned GC, elevates five to partner

First ESG-centred global VC fund in Japan launches with the help of Withers

Most Read Articles

Lander & Rogers welcomes renowned GC, elevates five to partner

Moray & Agnew adds personal injury team to Sydney office

DWF IT specialists join Hamilton Locke

Leading firms help Western Sydney airport terminal take off