Police accused of misconduct lose High Court evidence appeal

Two Victorian police officers have lost an appeal to avoid giving evidence at an anti-corruption watchdog hearing.

Two Victorian police officers accused of misconduct had lost an appeal to avoid giving evidence at an anti-corruption watchdog hearing.

The police officers, accused of kicking and stomping on a 51-year-old woman, are facing examination by the Victorian Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission, which began an investigation following the finding of CCTV footage.

The woman, who had mental health issues, was allegedly left handcuffed and semi-naked on the ground when she was brought into the Ballarat lockup last year.  The officers face allegations they used unreasonable force.

Lawyers for the officers argued that giving evidence might compromise fairness at a possible future trial, but because they had not been charged with an offence, nor were any prosecutions pending, the court said there was no risk to a future trial and rejected their appeal.

According to the ABC, the court found that there was no reason to extend the principle to cover the current case and that doing so would “fetter the pursuit and exposure of a lack of probity within the force contrary to the object of the IBAC Act”.

The court also found that the IBAC Act lawfully removed the privilege against self-incrimination, a question central to the case in the High Court challenging the examination by IBAC in public.

A new hearing date is yet to be set.
 

Recent articles & video

Allens guides Morgan Stanley in landmark infrastructure deal

Rigby Cooke welcomes experienced litigator as partner

Gilbert + Tobin expands partnership with key promotions

NSW solicitors honored in King’s Birthday Awards

First-ever cohort of the best dealmakers in Australia and New Zealand unveiled

International Bar Association reveals legal sector's US$ 1.6 trillion contribution to global economy

Most Read Articles

Clyde & Co cohort crosses over to Kennedys

Four join Corrs partnership in promotions round

Moray & Agnew pumps up partnership with corporate lawyer

Federal Court rules against cosmetics company for misleading conduct and trademark infringement