Lighter Side: Moral quandary in Chinese bar exam

Question: Would you save your girlfriend or your mother from a burning building?

Choosing between saving your girlfriend or mother from a burning building is a moral quandary most would not expect to encounter in their day-to-day lives.

But, if you’re a Chinese judge, you’re expected to know the correct answer.

According to Above the Law, that questions was on this year’s National Judicial Examination - essentially the bar exam for Chinese judges. 

So what is the correct answer? The Chinese Ministry of Justice posted it recently. From BBC: 

“[E]xam writers are duty-bound to save their mothers. It would be a “crime of non-action” to choose romantic love over filial duty.”

That is in contrast to our common law system, where we generally don’t criminally punish people for a failure to act or omission.

Recent articles & video

MinterEllison partnership balloons after nine promotions

McCullough Robertson announces pro bono collab with Queensland Ballet

Invesco taps Clayton Utz for advice on Stockland partnership

Ashurst study: Gen-AI helped 88% of respondents 'feel more prepared for the future'

Allens guides Morgan Stanley in landmark infrastructure deal

Rigby Cooke welcomes experienced litigator as partner

Most Read Articles

Four join Corrs partnership in promotions round

First-ever cohort of the best dealmakers in Australia and New Zealand unveiled

Federal Court rules against cosmetics company for misleading conduct and trademark infringement

Lander & Rogers helps Team Global Express with $190m refinancing