US legal start-up files counterclaim against Thomson Reuters

The San Francisco start-up accuses the media giant of anticompetitive practices

US legal start-up files counterclaim against Thomson Reuters

San Francisco-based legal start-up ROSS Intelligence has filed a counterclaim against media giant Thomson Reuters, alleging that the media conglomerate uses “anticompetitive tactics” to protect its dominance in the legal research market, according to a Law360 report.

The filing follows a lawsuit brought by Thomson Reuters last May that accused ROSS Intelligence of working with a third party to illegally obtain copyrighted material from its legal research platform, Westlaw, to create a competing service.

The start-up denied unlawfully copying case summaries and other “critical features” of Westlaw, filing a motion to dismiss the case last July. And in December, ROSS announced that it would be shutting down its operations because of mounting costs and an inability to secure funding stemming from Thomson Reuters’ lawsuit.

In its countersuit, ROSS lamented being “forced to exit the market” because of “Westlaw’s anticompetitive practices.”

“Westlaw does not maintain its exalted status in legal search through innovation or procompetitive business practices,” according to ROSS’ claim obtained by Law360. “Instead, counter defendants use anticompetitive sales and licensing regimes supported by a web of sham copyrights and intimidation tactics to crush potential rivals.”

“Its unfortunate experience illustrates how Westlaw uses exclusionary tactics to harm nascent rivals, deter investment and entry, and protect its market position,” the company said.

The media giant is represented by Jack B. Blumenfeld and Michael J. Flynn of Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell LLP, and Kirkland & Ellis LLP’s Dale M. Cendali, Joshua L. Simmons, and Eric A. Loverro.

Meanwhile, ROSS’ legal team consists of Gabriel M. Ramsey, Kayvan M. Ghaffari, Mark A. Klapow, Joshua M. Rychlinski, Jacob Canter, and Lisa Kimmel of Crowell & Moring LLP, and Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP’s David E. Moore and Stephanie E. O’Byrne.

Recent articles & video

Sparke Helmore appoints Brisbane partner as new board member

Central West firms pitch in pro bono for flood victims

Sidley enters the Middle East market with new hire

Hall & Wilcox outgoing chair of partners to lead international legal org

DLA Piper assists Aurecon on Market Advisory Group acquisition

Highlight: Australia among the most litigious countries for personal injury

Most Read Articles

The leading lawyers and law firms in Australian personal injury law for 2022

SPB welcomes new managing partner for Sydney

Hall & Wilcox outgoing chair of partners to lead international legal org

Piper Alderman appoints real estate partner from Moray & Agnew