Judge says Court of Appeal got Baden-Clay case wrong

A retired Supreme Court judge has said why he thinks the Court of Appeal shouldn’t have downgraded Gerard Baden-Clay’s murder conviction.

Judge says Court of Appeal got Baden-Clay case wrong
The Courier Mail has today published the opinion of a retired Supreme Court judge, who has spoken out about the controversial downgrading of Gerard Baden Clay’s murder conviction by the Court of Appeal.

“The simple fact is that the Court of Appeal got it wrong,” he said.

The former interstate judge has withheld his identity to avoid controversy, according to The Courier Mail.

“The Court of Appeal completely endorsed the view that the evidence in the Baden-Clay case was capable of supporting the conclusion that the appellant had caused his wife’s death by an unlawful act but they reasoned that in the particular circumstances a finding of an intent to kill could not be sustained.

“To reach this conclusion the Court embarked upon a detailed assessment of the evidence given at the trial and consideration of competing submissions by counsel during the appeal.

“I have not had an opportunity to read the transcript of the evidence given at the trial but I have no reason to believe that the Court of Appeal in its judgment has failed to mention any relevant part of the evidence as to the circumstances surrounding the killing of Mrs Baden-Clay,” he said.

Read his full opinion on The Courier Mail website.


Free newsletter

Subscribe to our FREE newsletter service and we’ll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Please enter your email address below and click on Sign Up for daily newsletters from Australasian Lawyer.

Recent articles & video

HSF pumps up global financial services regulatory team with new partner

DLA Piper supports nickel pig iron producer on $231m equity raising effort

US Supreme Court rejects government request that keeps inmates at high risk for COVID-19

Clayton Utz senior associate applauds greater focus on diversity and inclusion

Ashurst helps challenger bank gain unicorn status on $230m capital raising

UK lord chief justice pitches use of temporary venues for court proceedings

Most Read Articles

Cosmetics giant makes first foray into Australia with Hall & Wilcox’s assistance

KWM's chief executive partner for Australia extends run into second term

Clayton Utz senior associate applauds greater focus on diversity and inclusion

COVID-19 and Australian courts and legal bodies updates: 25 May