Court of Appeal urges judges give harsher incest sentences

Victoria’s Court of Appeal is calling for harsher sentences for incest after a claim that sentences are disproportionately low.

The highest court in Victoria has urged judges to impose harsher punishment for incest cases but also did not overturn a debated incest sentence for a man proven guilty of incest against his two step-daughters.

The Court of Appeal wrote in a judgment that judges were doling out “disproportionately low” sentences for incest, according to The Age.

In the controversial case brought to the appellate, the man was sentenced to five-and-a-half years in prison, even though he impregnated the 13-year-old step-daughter he abused. Incest has a maximum penalty of 25 years.

The young teen was later forced to terminate the pregnancy, saying instead that she was having sex with a boy from her school because she feared the consequences of telling the truth. She then had to endure continuous abuse by the man.

Pleading guilty to incest and indecent assault, the man was given three-and-a-half years in prison for committing incest against his 13-year-old step-daughter.

Her sister, according to The Age, had a mild mental disability and was 15 or 16 when she was abused. The man got two years in prison for his crimes against the older teen.

The court said that if the sentence weren’t consistent with current practice, “we would have had no hesitation in concluding that the sentence imposed...was manifestly inadequate.”

This is why the court believes it falls on judges to collectively be handing out harsher sentences to those convicted of incest.

“Sentencing for incest must reflect society's denunciation of the sexual abuse of children and the profound harm which it causes,” the court wrote. "The very high maximum penalty underlines the seriousness with which the offence is regarded."
 

Recent articles & video

Gadens to merge with Canberra firm

Clio's APAC GM was a linguistics student who 'never considered' a career in legal

Majority of Australian legal professionals think AI use is ethical: report

Nominations for Elite Women 2024 close next week

Kain Lawyers scoops up ex-PwC Australia legal business head as director

US federal judge upholds law suspending 97-year-old appeals judge

Most Read Articles

Hall & Wilcox helps CHG-Meridian acquire asset portfolio from Maia Financial

Maurice Blackburn director to helm the Australian Lawyers Alliance as national president

Kain Lawyers scoops up ex-PwC Australia legal business head as director

Lawyers seek access to Johnson & Johnson communications in talcum powder lawsuit